431 Columbus Avenue, Sandusky, OH 44870
- 0.8 acres
- Built 1895
About this property
A landmark property with endless possibilities in the heart of Sandusky! Rich in character, history, and opportunity, this extraordinary former church offers roughly 25,000 square feet of versatile space just moments from downtown Sandusky's waterfront, dining, entertainment, and attractions. Currently operating as the income-producing Lost Sailor Inn vacation rental, this one-of-a-kind property presents an exceptional opportunity for investors, entrepreneurs, and visionary buyers alike. The impressive main level features soaring ceilings, expansive gathering spaces, and a distinctive sanctuary with movable partition wall that can be raised or lowered to create separation or an open connection. There are multiple bedrooms and two baths, a kitchen, and flexible living areas. Additional accommodations include a private lower-level efficiency apartment with kitchenette and full bath and two upper-level bedrooms. A sprawling basement offers even more possibilities for recreation, entertainment, business operations, or creative redevelopment. Notable features include elevator access, multiple entrances, a generous front porch, substantial on-site parking, and numerous mechanical updates. Original features include stained-glass windows and ceiling dome, operational organ, beautiful woodwork and large, wooden paneled doors. Continue its successful short-term rental operation, explore a boutique inn or bed-and-breakfast concept, or envision an event venue, wedding destination, retreat center, creative studio, community gathering space, or mixed-use investment. Its unique architecture and flexible layout invite countless possibilities. Ideally situated near Sandusky's vibrant downtown, Lake Erie waterfront, parks, cultural attractions, and Cedar Point, this remarkable property combines location, scale, character, and income potential in one truly distinctive offering. A rare opportunity to preserve a piece of Sandusky's history while creating its next chapter.
Key facts
- Status
- Coming Soon
- Type
- Mixed Use
- Days on market
- 0
- Property taxes
- about $4,104/yr
- County
- Erie
- MLS #
- 226039614
- Listing brokerage
- Coldwell Banker Realty
- Listing agent
- Ashley D Spencer
- Listing brokerage contact
- 614-880-0808
Lot and parking
- Lot size
- 0.8 acres
- Lot square feet
- 34,848
- Total parking
- 50
Systems and utilities
- Heating
- Steam
- Water
- Public
Taxes and HOA
- Property taxes
- about $4,104 a year
- Tax year
- 2025
- Parcel number
- 56-68034-000
Around it
Erie County: 5 homes for sale. Town: everything for sale in Sandusky.
Is it priced right?
Curious how this home is listed relative to fair market value? Send a request and I'll run a report for you and send it to you. Asking prices are the seller's opinion. What the homes around it sold for is the market's.
Own a home nearby? Pick the second option and I'll value yours instead.
Shown here through the MLS IDX program by Blacktree Realty. Listing information is provided by the Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings held by brokerages other than Blacktree Realty are identified with the listing brokerage's name. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated Oct 19, 2026, 6:13 PM.